The decision to drop the atomic bomb
The recent 80th anniversary of the dropping of the atomic bomb on Hiroshima brought to mind some thoughts I'd had when I was watching the Oppenheimer movie a little while ago, and so I thought I'd finally get around to writing them up. Ultimately Truman thought that dropping the atomic bombs was the best way to bring about Japan's unconditional surrender and its hard to disagree about that. The most obvious alternative at the time would have been a land invasion of Japan. One can certainly have "clean" land combat that takes place far away from most civilian residences and which is a matter of combat between professionals. That wasn't what had been seen recently in the Pacific war though. The recent Battle of Manila fought as the Allies liberated the Philippines saw the death of around 20,000 soldiers but 100,000 Filipino civilians. In taking Okinawa 100,000 soldiers died and about 100,000 of island's 300,000 civilians, some because they h...